Fishing Kayak vs Touring Kayak: Detailed Comparison 

Choosing between a fishing kayak and a touring kayak can feel like comparing apples and oranges. Both float and move through water, but their designs and purposes couldn’t be more different.

Fishing kayaks are built for stability and storage. They’re perfect for those who want to cast a line and reel in the big one. These kayaks often have wider hulls and special features for anglers.

Touring kayaks, on the other hand, are sleek and swift. They’re designed for covering long distances and exploring new horizons. Their narrow shape helps them cut through water efficiently.

The right choice depends on your goals on the water. Do you want to spend hours fishing in one spot? Or do you dream of paddling for miles along the coastline?

Each type of kayak has its strengths and weaknesses. Understanding these can help you pick the perfect kayak for your needs. When comparing a fishing kayak vs regular kayak, it’s important to understand their unique features. Let’s explore what makes fishing and touring kayaks unique.

Key Differences at a Glance

FeatureFishing KayakTouring Kayak
StabilityHighModerate
SpeedModerateHigh
ManeuverabilityModerateHigh
StorageSpecializedGeneral
Length10-14 feet14-18 feet
Width30-36 inches22-25 inches

This table provides a quick fishing kayak comparison with touring kayaks.

Design and Construction

Fishing kayaks and touring kayaks look different for good reasons. Their designs reflect their specific uses on the water. Understanding the differences between a touring kayak vs fishing kayak is crucial for choosing the right one for your needs.

Fishing Kayak Design

Fishing kayaks are built with stability in mind. They have wide hulls that help you stay upright when casting or reeling in a fish. This design makes them less likely to tip over, even in choppy water.

Many models offer a sit-on-top configuration, which allows for easy movement and access to gear. These kayaks often come equipped with rod holders and gear mounts, making them ideal for organizing fishing accessories.

Rod holders and gear mounts are key features of fishing kayaks. These built-in accessories keep your fishing rods secure and within easy reach. They also provide spots to attach fish finders, GPS units, and other helpful tools.

Touring Kayak Design

Touring kayaks have a very different shape. Their hulls are narrow and long, which helps them slice through the water efficiently. This design allows for faster paddling and straighter tracking over long distances.

Unlike fishing kayaks, touring kayaks usually have a sit-inside configuration. You sit lower in the kayak, with your legs inside the hull. This design helps protect you from wind and waves, making it easier to paddle for hours.

Efficiency is the name of the game for touring kayaks. Their streamlined shape reduces drag in the water. This means you can paddle further with less effort, perfect for long trips or multi-day adventures.

Performance on the Water

How a kayak behaves on the water can make or break your experience. Fishing and touring kayaks each have their own strengths when it comes to performance. When comparing fishing vs touring kayak performance, each type excels in different areas. Fishing kayaks prioritize stability and maneuverability in confined spaces while touring kayaks focus on speed and efficiency over long distances.

Stability and Maneuverability

Fishing kayaks shine when it comes to stability. Their wide, flat bottoms help you stay steady when casting or fighting a fish. You can often stand up in these kayaks without tipping over, which is great for sight fishing or stretching your legs.

Touring kayaks, while less stable, offer better agility. They turn more easily and respond quickly to paddle strokes. This makes them ideal for navigating tight spaces or dealing with changing water conditions.

Speed and Tracking

When it comes to speed, touring kayaks take the lead. Their long, narrow shape allows them to cut through water with less resistance. This means you can cover more distance with each paddle stroke, making long trips easier.

Fishing kayaks aren’t built for speed, but they often have features to help with tracking. Some models include a keel or rudder to help them stay on course. While they won’t win any races, they can still get you where you need to go.

Storage and Equipment Options

Different kayak designs offer different storage solutions. Let’s look at how fishing and touring kayaks handle gear storage.

Fishing Kayak Storage Solutions

Fishing kayaks are all about convenient gear access. They often have built-in rod holders to keep your fishing rods secure and ready to use. Many models also include mounting points for fish finders and other electronic devices, enhancing the fishing experience.

For serious anglers, some fishing kayaks come with live wells to keep bait or caught fish fresh. Coolers are another common feature, perfect for storing drinks or your catch of the day.

Touring Kayak Cargo Capacity

Touring kayaks focus on dry storage for multi-day trips. They usually have watertight hatches and bulkheads to keep your gear dry, even if water gets into the kayak.

Deck rigging, like bungee cords or nets on the kayak’s top, provides easy access to gear you might need while paddling. This setup is great for storing maps, snacks, or safety equipment within arm’s reach.

Top Fishing Kayak Recommendations

We’ve tested numerous models to find the best options for different needs and budgets. Our top picks offer a mix of stability, features, and value that will enhance your time on the water.

Best Overall: Old Town Sportsman AutoPilot 120

SpecificationDetail
Length12 feet
Width37 inches
Weight152 pounds
Capacity558 pounds
Motor45-pound thrust 12V Minn Kota

The Old Town Sportsman AutoPilot 120 stands out as the best overall fishing kayak due to its impressive features and performance. This kayak combines stability, advanced technology, and ample storage to create an unparalleled fishing experience.

The standout feature is the Minn Kota motor with Spot-Lock technology, which allows you to maintain your position effortlessly, even in windy conditions or strong currents. The remote-controlled motor gives you the freedom to focus on fishing without worrying about drifting away from your spot.

In our tests, we found the AutoPilot 120 to be incredibly stable, making it easy to stand and cast. The comfortable mesh seat provides excellent support for long days on the water. The four 18-inch accessory tracks offer plenty of options for customizing your setup with rod holders, fish finders, and other accessories.

The only downside we noticed is the kayak’s weight, which can make transportation challenging. However, if you have the means to transport it, the AutoPilot 120 offers an exceptional fishing experience that’s hard to beat.

Best Value: Pelican Catch PWR 100

SpecificationDetail
Length9’9″
Width39.75″
Weight75 lbs
Capacity450 lbs
MotorCompatible with gas or electric (up to 2.5 hp)

The Pelican Catch PWR 100 offers excellent value for anglers looking for a motorized fishing kayak without breaking the bank. This compact powerhouse packs a lot of features into a more affordable package.

One of the standout features of the Catch PWR 100 is its versatility. It can be paddled traditionally or powered by a motor, giving you options depending on your fishing location and preferences. The Ergo360 seat is a comfortable addition, allowing you to swivel and adjust your position easily.

During our tests, we found the Catch PWR 100 to be remarkably stable for its size, thanks to its wide hull design. The open deck layout provides ample space for standing and casting, which is impressive for a kayak under 10 feet long.

We did notice that while the kayak performs well in calm waters, it can be challenging to control in windy conditions due to its shorter length. However, for its price point and feature set, the Catch PWR 100 offers great value for anglers looking to get into motorized kayak fishing.

Most Versatile: Bonafide SS127

SpecificationDetail
Length12’7″
Width33.75″
Weight94 lbs
Capacity475 lbs
PropulsionPaddle

The Bonafide SS127 earns its spot as the most versatile fishing kayak due to its exceptional stability, clever design features, and adaptability to various fishing styles and environments.

The SS127’s hybrid catamaran hull design provides outstanding stability, allowing anglers to stand and fish with confidence. The HiRise seating system offers multiple positions, including a high position that gives you a better vantage point for sight fishing.

In our tests, we were impressed by the SS127’s balance of stability and maneuverability. The kayak tracks well in open water but can also navigate tighter spaces with ease. The ample storage options, including the innovative DryPod and under-seat Junk Drawer, allow you to bring along all your gear without cluttering the deck.

We found the SS127 comfortable during long fishing sessions. The stability and seating options make it possible to fish all day without fatigue. The thoughtful design touches, like the PerchPads for elevated standing and the multiple rod management systems, add to its versatility.

The only drawback we noticed is that the SS127 is on the heavier side for a non-motorized kayak, which can make transportation and launching a bit more challenging. However, we believe that the stability and features more than make up for the extra weight.

Top Touring Kayak Recommendations

Touring kayaks are designed for long-distance paddling and extended trips on open water. They offer a blend of speed, efficiency, and storage capacity that sets them apart from other kayak types. Here are our top picks based on extensive testing and performance analysis.

Best Performance: Stellar S16

SpecificationDetail
Length16 feet
Width22 inches
Weight50 lbs
Capacity400 lbs
PropulsionPaddle

The Stellar S16 stands out as a top performer in the touring kayak category. At 16 feet long and 22 inches wide, this kayak is built for speed and efficiency on the water.

The S16’s sleek design allows it to cut through waves with minimal resistance. Its narrow beam contributes to impressive tracking, keeping you on course even in challenging conditions. Paddlers consistently praise the S16’s ability to maintain high speeds with less effort, making it ideal for long-distance touring.

During our tests, we found the S16 to be remarkably responsive and easy to maneuver despite its length. The kayak’s stability is well-balanced, offering enough primary stability for comfort without sacrificing the secondary stability needed for lean turns.

One of the standout features of the S16 is its lightweight construction. Available in various materials, even the standard fiberglass version is notably lighter than many competitors, making it easier to transport and handle on land.

Best for Beginners: Wilderness Systems Tempest 165

SpecificationDetail
Length16.5 feet
Width21.5 inches
Weight56 lbs
Capacity300 lbs
PropulsionPaddle

The Wilderness Systems Tempest 165 earns our recommendation as the best touring kayak for beginners. At 16’6″ long and 21.5″ wide, it offers a great balance of stability and performance that new paddlers will appreciate.

The Tempest 165’s slightly wider beam provides excellent initial stability, giving beginners the confidence they need when first starting out. At the same time, it maintains enough secondary stability to allow for growth as skills improve.

We found the Tempest 165 to be forgiving and easy to control, even in windier conditions. The kayak tracks well and responds predictably to steering inputs, which is crucial for those still developing their paddling technique.

Comfort is another strong point of the Tempest 165. The Phase 3 AirPro seating system offers multiple adjustment points, allowing paddlers to find their ideal position for long days on the water. The spacious cockpit also makes entry and exit easier for newcomers.

Best Lightweight Option: Eddyline Fathom

SpecificationDetail
Length16.5 feet
Width22 inches
Weight50 lbs
Capacity350 lbs
PropulsionPaddle

For paddlers prioritizing portability without sacrificing performance, the Eddyline Fathom is our top pick. This 16’6″ kayak weighs in at just 50 pounds, making it one of the lightest options in its class.

The Fathom’s thermoformed ABS plastic construction offers an excellent balance of durability and weight savings. In our tests, we found it to be surprisingly resistant to scratches and impacts while remaining easy to carry and load onto a vehicle.

On the water, the Fathom performs like a much heavier kayak. It tracks well and maintains speed efficiently, thanks to its sleek hull design. The kayak’s stability is well-suited for intermediate to advanced paddlers, offering a nice balance of primary and secondary stability.

One of the Fathom’s standout features is its responsiveness. It turns quickly when needed but also holds its course well during long stretches of paddling. This versatility makes it suitable for a variety of water conditions, from calm lakes to coastal exploration.

What’s The Difference Between A Fishing Kayak And A Regular Kayak

Fishing kayaks and regular kayaks have distinct features designed for their specific purposes. Understanding these differences can help you choose the right kayak for your needs. Let’s compare their key characteristics:

FeatureFishing KayakRegular Kayak
StabilityHigher stability for casting and standingModerate stability, focused on efficient paddling
SpeedSlower, prioritizes stabilityFaster, designed for covering distances
StorageSpecialized compartments for fishing gearGeneral storage for personal items and camping gear
SeatingOften includes elevated, adjustable seatsUsually has a basic, low-profile seat
WidthWider for increased stabilityNarrower for better speed and tracking
AccessoriesRod holders, gear mounts, fish findersMinimal built-in accessories

Choosing the Right Kayak for Your Needs

When selecting between a fishing kayak and a touring kayak, consider your intended use and the water conditions you’ll encounter most frequently. Fishing kayaks are ideal for anglers who prioritize stability and storage for gear while touring kayaks are better suited for those looking to cover long distances efficiently.

  1. Intended use and water conditions: Consider where you’ll be paddling most often. Open oceans, protected bays, lakes, or rivers all have different requirements.
  2. Skill level and experience: Be honest about your current abilities and choose a kayak that matches your skill level while allowing room for growth.
  3. Storage and transportation requirements: Consider your storage and transportation requirements as well. Some kayaks may be too large for easy transport, while others, like inflatable fishing kayaks, offer more convenient storage and portability options.
  4. Kayak dimensions: The length, width, and volume of the kayak affect its speed, stability, and carrying capacity. Longer kayaks are generally faster but harder to maneuver, while wider kayaks offer more stability.
  5. Comfort features: Look for adjustable footrests, comfortable seating systems, and adequate cockpit size to ensure you’ll be comfortable during long paddles.

Remember, the best kayak for you is one that matches your specific needs, skill level, and paddling ambitions. Take your time, do your research, and choose a kayak that will enhance your enjoyment of the sport for years to come. Whether you’re deciding between a fishing kayak vs regular kayak or a touring model, consider your specific requirements.

Share Your Love