Is A Sit On Top Kayak Better For Fishing?

Fishing from a kayak opens up a world of possibilities. You can reach spots that bigger boats can’t, sneak up on fish without spooking them, and enjoy the peace of being on the water. But when it comes to choosing a kayak for fishing, one question comes up a lot: Is a sit-on-top kayak better? 

We’ve spent countless hours on the water, testing different kayaks in various conditions. We’ve fished in calm lakes, choppy seas, and winding rivers. After all this hands-on experience, we can say with confidence that sit-on-top kayaks often come out on top for fishing. But it’s not a one-size-fits-all answer. Your perfect kayak depends on where you fish, what you fish for, and how you like to fish.

In this guide, we’ll break down the pros and cons of sit-on-top kayaks for fishing. We’ll share our real-world experiences and help you decide if a sit-on-top kayak is the right choice for your fishing adventures.

Understanding Sit-On-Top Kayaks

Sit-on-top kayaks are exactly what they sound like – kayaks where you sit on top of the deck, not inside a cockpit. This open design is what sets them apart from traditional sit-inside kayaks.

Design Features

Sit-on-top kayaks have a few key design features:

• Open deck: The most noticeable feature is the open deck. There’s no enclosed cockpit – you sit right on top of the kayak.
• Scupper holes: These are small holes that allow water to drain out of the kayak. They’re a key feature for keeping you dry.
• Molded-in seats: Many sit-on-top kayaks have seats molded right into the deck, though some have removable seats for added comfort.
• Storage areas: Most have open storage areas at the front and back, often with bungee cords to secure your gear.

Types of Sit-On-Top Kayaks

Not all sit-on-top kayaks are the same. Here are some common types you’ll encounter:

1. Recreational sit-on-tops: These are general-purpose kayaks, good for calm waters and casual fishing.
2. Fishing-specific sit-on-tops: These come with features like rod holders and tackle storage built-in.
3. Pedal-drive sit-on-tops: These have a pedal system for hands-free propulsion, great for covering long distances.
4. Inflatable sit-on-tops: These can be deflated for easy storage and transport, perfect if you have limited space.

When choosing a sit-on-top kayak for fishing, consider which type best fits your needs and fishing style.

Advantages of Sit-On-Top Kayaks for Fishing

After extensive testing, we’ve found that sit-on-top kayaks offer several key advantages for fishing. Here’s what stands out:

Stability

One of the biggest pros of sit-on-top kayaks is their stability. The wide, flat design gives you a solid platform for casting and reeling in fish. We’ve found that even in choppy conditions, sit-on-tops feel secure and stable.

Many sit-on-top fishing kayaks are stable enough to stand up in. This is a game-changer for sight fishing or when you need a better vantage point to cast. We’ve successfully stood and fished in models like the Old Town Topwater and the Hobie Mirage Pro Angler without feeling wobbly.

Ease of Use

Sit-on-top kayaks are incredibly user-friendly, especially for beginners. Getting in and out is as simple as stepping on and sitting down. There’s no need to master the art of sliding into a narrow cockpit.

If you do happen to capsize (which is rare given their stability), it’s much easier to get back on a sit-on-top. We’ve practiced self-rescue in various conditions, and it’s always been easier with a sit-on-top compared to a sit-inside kayak.

Comfort

Comfort is crucial when you’re spending long hours fishing. Sit-on-top kayaks often have adjustable, lawn chair-style seats that provide excellent back support. Models like the Wilderness Systems ATAK 120 and the Bonafide SS127 have some of the most comfortable seats we’ve tested.

The open design also means you have freedom to move around, stretch your legs, and change positions. This is a big plus on long fishing trips.

Storage and Accessibility

When it comes to storing and accessing fishing gear, sit-on-top kayaks shine. Most have open storage areas at the bow and stern, perfect for tackle boxes, coolers, and dry bags. Many also feature built-in rod holders and gear tracks for customizing your setup.

We’ve found it much easier to access gear on a sit-on-top compared to reaching into the hatches of a sit-inside kayak. Everything is right there at your fingertips, which means less fumbling and more fishing.

Versatility

Sit-on-top kayaks are versatile performers in various water conditions. We’ve successfully used them in calm lakes, slow-moving rivers, and even coastal waters. Their stability makes them suitable for a wide range of fishing techniques, from trolling to fly fishing.

Many sit-on-top fishing kayaks, like the Jackson Kayak Bite, can be customized with accessories like fish finders, anchor systems, and camera mounts. This versatility allows you to tailor your kayak to your specific fishing needs.

Potential Drawbacks of Sit-On-Top Kayaks

While sit-on-top kayaks have many advantages for fishing, they’re not perfect for every situation. Here are some potential drawbacks to consider:

Exposure to Elements

The open design that makes sit-on-top kayaks so accessible also leaves you more exposed to the elements. In cold or rainy conditions, you’ll feel the chill more than in a sit-inside kayak. We’ve found that dressing appropriately and using a spray skirt can help, but it’s something to keep in mind if you fish in colder climates.

Speed and Efficiency

Generally, sit-on-top kayaks are slower and less efficient to paddle than sit-inside kayaks. Their wider, flatter design creates more drag in the water. If you need to cover long distances to reach your fishing spots, this could be a consideration.

However, many fishing-specific sit-on-top kayaks now come with pedal drives or even motors, which can offset this disadvantage. We’ve found pedal kayaks like the Hobie Mirage Pro Angler to be excellent for covering ground quickly and efficiently.

Weight

Sit-on-top fishing kayaks tend to be heavier than their sit-inside counterparts. This can make transportation and launching more challenging, especially if you’re fishing solo. We’ve found that using a kayak cart can make a big difference in getting your kayak to and from the water.

Cost

Fishing-specific sit-on-top kayaks, especially those with advanced features like pedal drives, can be more expensive than basic sit-inside kayaks. However, we believe the added features and comfort often justify the cost for serious anglers.

Comparing Sit-On-Top and Sit-In Kayaks for Fishing

To help you make an informed decision, let’s compare sit-on-top and sit-inside kayaks across several key factors:

Stability

• Sit-On-Top: Generally more stable due to wider, flatter hull design. Easier to get back on if capsized.
• Sit-In: Can be stable, but typically less so than sit-on-tops. More challenging to recover from a capsize.

Comfort

• Sit-On-Top: Open design allows for more movement and stretching. Often have more comfortable, adjustable seats.
• Sit-In: More protection from elements, but can feel confining on long trips. Seating comfort varies widely.

Storage

• Sit-On-Top: Open storage areas are easily accessible. Many fishing-specific models have built-in rod holders and tackle storage.
• Sit-In: More enclosed storage, which keeps gear drier. Can be harder to access while on the water.

Performance

• Sit-On-Top: Generally slower and less efficient to paddle, but often more maneuverable in tight spaces.
• Sit-In: Usually faster and more efficient for covering long distances.

Versatility

• Sit-On-Top: Excellent for fishing in various conditions. Easy to customize with accessories.
• Sit-In: Better for rough water and long-distance touring. Less easy to customize for fishing.

Safety

• Sit-On-Top: Self-bailing design, easier to re-enter if capsized. Better for beginners.
• Sit-In: Requires more skill to handle in case of capsize. Better protection from cold water.

After extensive testing in various conditions, we’ve found that for most fishing scenarios, the advantages of sit-on-top kayaks outweigh their drawbacks. However, the best choice depends on your specific needs, fishing style, and local conditions.

Top Sit-On-Top Fishing Kayaks

Based on our testing and feedback from experienced anglers, here are some of the best sit-on-top fishing kayaks currently available:

Old Town Topwater 120

The Old Town Topwater 120 is a standout for its stability and comfort. We found it exceptionally easy to stand and fish from, even in choppy conditions. Its DoubleU hull design provides excellent tracking and stability without sacrificing speed.

Hobie Mirage Pro Angler 14

For those who want the ultimate in hands-free fishing, the Hobie Mirage Pro Angler 14 is hard to beat. Its MirageDrive 180 pedal system allows for efficient, hands-free propulsion in forward and reverse.

Wilderness Systems Radar 135

The Wilderness Systems Radar 135 offers versatility with its tri-powered design. It can be paddled, pedaled, or motorized, adapting to various fishing conditions. We found its AirPro MAX seat to be one of the most comfortable we’ve tested.

Bonafide SS127

The Bonafide SS127 is a favorite among anglers for its exceptional stability and fishing-friendly features. Its hybrid catamaran hull design provides a stable platform for stand-up fishing.

Perception Pescador Pro 12

For those on a budget, the Perception Pescador Pro 12 offers excellent value. It provides many features of higher-end fishing kayaks at a more accessible price point.

Remember, the best kayak for you depends on your specific needs, fishing style, and the waters you’ll be exploring. Consider factors like your budget, the need for speed versus stability, and the types of fishing you’ll be doing when making your choice.

Choosing the Right Sit-On-Top Fishing Kayak

Selecting the perfect sit-on-top fishing kayak involves considering several factors. Here’s what to keep in mind:

Fishing Environment

Think about where you’ll be fishing most often. Different kayaks are designed for different water conditions:

• Calm lakes and ponds: Most sit-on-top kayaks work well here. Focus on comfort and storage.
• Rivers: Look for shorter, more maneuverable kayaks with good tracking.
• Coastal waters: Choose a longer kayak with a rudder for better handling in waves and currents.

Kayak Length

Kayak length affects speed, maneuverability, and storage capacity:

• Shorter kayaks (9-12 feet): More maneuverable, easier to transport. Good for rivers and tight spaces.
• Medium length (12-14 feet): Good all-rounders. Balance speed and maneuverability.
• Longer kayaks (14+ feet): Faster and track straighter. Better for covering long distances.

Width and Stability

Wider kayaks are generally more stable, which is great for stand-up fishing. However, they’re slower and less efficient to paddle. Consider your priorities:

• Extra-wide (34-36 inches): Maximum stability for stand-up fishing.
• Standard width (28-32 inches): Good balance of stability and speed.

Weight Capacity

Make sure the kayak can handle your weight plus all your gear. We recommend choosing a kayak with a capacity at least 125-150 pounds more than your body weight.

Propulsion Method

Decide how you want to move your kayak:

• Paddle: Traditional and versatile. Good for most fishing situations.
• Pedal: Allows hands-free operation. Great for covering long distances and trolling.
• Motor: Effortless movement. Best for large bodies of water.

Comfort Features

Look for features that will keep you comfortable during long fishing sessions:

• Adjustable, padded seat
• Footrests
• Ample legroom

Storage and Accessories

Consider what gear you’ll be bringing and look for kayaks with appropriate storage options:

• Rod holders
• Tackle storage
• Cooler space
• Gear tracks for adding accessories

By carefully considering these factors, you can choose a sit-on-top fishing kayak that perfectly matches your needs and fishing style. Remember, the best kayak is the one that gets you out on the water most often!

Customizing Your Sit-On-Top Fishing Kayak

One of the great advantages of sit-on-top fishing kayaks is how easy they are to customize. Here are some ways to make your kayak work even better for you:

Adding Rod Holders

Extra rod holders can be a game-changer. They allow you to troll multiple lines or keep rods handy for quick changes. Flush-mount or adjustable rod holders can be added to most sit-on-top kayaks with basic tools.

Installing a Fishfinder

A fish finder can significantly improve your catch rate. Many sit-on-top kayaks have space for mounting a fish finder and running the transducer cable. We’ve found that even a basic fish finder can make a big difference in locating fish. If you’re unsure about the installation process, check out our guide on how to install a fish finder on a kayak.

Anchor Systems

An anchor system helps you stay in place when fishing in windy conditions or currents. Anchor trolleys allow you to position your anchor point along the side of your kayak, giving you more control.

Storage Solutions

While most fishing kayaks come with built-in storage, you can always add more. Milk crates, deck bags, and tackle management systems can help keep your gear organized and accessible.

Lighting

If you plan on fishing at dawn, dusk, or night, adding lights to your kayak is crucial for safety. Navigation lights are often required by law, and additional LED lights can help you see your gear in low light conditions.

Propulsion Upgrades

Some sit-on-top kayaks can be upgraded with pedal drives or even small motors. This can greatly extend your range and allow for hands-free fishing. If you’re interested in motorized options, you might want to explore 2 person fishing kayaks with trolling motors.

Remember, while customizing your kayak can enhance your fishing experience, it’s important not to overload it. Always stay within the kayak’s weight capacity and ensure any modifications don’t compromise its stability or safety.

Maintaining Your Sit-On-Top Fishing Kayak

Proper maintenance will keep your sit-on-top fishing kayak in top condition for years to come. Here are some key maintenance tips:

• After each use, rinse your kayak with fresh water, especially if you’ve been in saltwater. This prevents salt and grime buildup. Use a mild soap for a deeper clean occasionally.
• Always dry your kayak before storage. This prevents mold and mildew growth. Pay special attention to scupper holes and storage